4 Worst Toaster Ovens to Avoid – Be Aware!

When it comes to preparing that delicious morning toast or quickly heating up those mini pizzas, a toaster oven is your trusty kitchen companion.

But like all things, not every toaster oven provides delicious output.

As your culinary expert, I’m here to highlight the worst toaster ovens to avoid, ensuring your mornings are filled with perfectly crisped delights.

For those who love convenience cooking, worst air fryers and bad waffler makers are another appliance category to be wary of.

Buckle up as we dive deep into the world of bad toaster ovens and help you steer clear of the pitfalls!

Worst Toaster Ovens

Worst Toaster Ovens

Due to uneven heating, reliability, and safety issues, the worst toaster ovens to avoid are Elite Gourmet ETO236, Total Chef 4-Slice, Commercial Chef, and Better Chef Basic.

1. Elite Gourmet ETO236

I was drawn to the Elite Gourmet ETO236 for its compact size and sleek black design. However, my experience was not as anticipated.

Firstly, the toaster tended to emit smoke, even at conservative temperatures. Smoke poured out on trying to toast a sandwich, resulting in unevenly toasted bread.

The absence of a crumb-catching tray also made clean-ups a chore. A more significant concern was the device’s safety.

The exterior gets excessively hot, potentially hazardous, especially near flammable materials. The need to unplug it after each use seemed peculiar.

Additionally, its tray lacked stability, causing food items to occasionally slide off.

While the Elite Gourmet ETO236 boasts a compact design, its performance and safety issues make it the least reliable toaster oven.

Those seeking a hassle-free toaster oven might want to consider other options.

2. Total Chef 4-Slice Toaster Oven

Toaster Ovens to Avoid

On paper, the Total Chef 4-Slice Natural Convection Toaster Oven sounded like a dream addition to my kitchen.

The product promised efficiency and ease with features like a timer, removable crumb tray, and automatic shut-off. 

Its chrome finish and stainless steel build were the cherries on top. But reality painted a different picture.

Temperature accuracy was a concern. Setting it at 270 F, I found it quickly surpassed this, reaching 330 F and affecting my meal’s outcome.

This inconsistency meant extra monitoring during use.

The inability to turn off the oven without unplugging was inconvenient and a safety red flag.

On top of that, during a session, I observed smoke emerging from the unit.

Lastly, the size was misleading. Advertised as a 4-slice oven, it struggled to fit even 2 slices, differing from the given dimensions.

In short, while the Total Chef has potential, its temperature accuracy, safety, and sizing challenges make it a less optimal choice for a reliable toaster oven.

3. Commercial Chef 10 Liter Toaster Oven

Following my experience with the Total Chef 4-Slice, I tried the Commercial Chef 10 Liter Toaster Oven.

The unit seemed good with its streamlined black design, convenient timer feature, and simple knob controls. But again, the reality was quite a mismatch from expectations.

Its performance reminded me that appearances can be deceiving, much like some of the brands highlighted in worst ovens and bad microwaves.

Starting with its heating capability, the oven had a peculiar tendency: it heated unevenly.

Rather than a uniformly toasted slice, there was a distinctive “stripe” across my toast.

 To make matters worse, parts of the toast were scorched while others remained undercooked. Such inconsistency took away the very essence of what a toaster oven should achieve.

Additionally, the oven arrived with visible damage, causing concerns about its durability.

Much like the Total Chef, the Commercial Chef Toaster Oven fell short of expectations. Despite its features, it left room for improvement in actual usage.

Bad Toaster Ovens

4. Better Chef Basic Toaster Oven

With its underwhelming features, the Better Chef Basic Toaster Oven easily finds its place alongside the bad bread makers I’ve encountered.

Right from the start, there was an issue with the heating elements.

While the top element toasted adequately, the bottom one tended to overcook, resulting in frequently burnt toast.

Its smaller size than anticipated, coupled with the absence of a separate cooking rack, highlighted its shortcomings as a poor quality toaster oven.

Moreover, customers pointed to challenges in dealing with the seller, from poor communication to difficulty reaching out.

Overall, the Better Chef Basic Toaster Oven didn’t quite meet the expectations set by its name.

Final Words

When searching for the perfect toaster oven, looking beyond the surface is essential.

It’s clear that while many products shine on paper, their real-world performances make them the worst toaster ovens.

Your mornings deserve the crisp perfection of toast and the savory warmth of mini pizzas, all without the hassle or worry.

You’re paving the way for many delicious meals by making informed choices.

Crystal Hafley Author

Crystal Hafley is a dedicated writer and content creator for WorstBrands, where she specializes in writing insightful reviews about kitchen appliances and fashion products.

With her expertise, Crystal provides readers with accurate and reliable information to help them make informed decisions about the brands and products they use every day. When she's not researching or writing, Crystal enjoys cooking and exploring the latest fashion trends.

Leave a Comment