When your oven’s broil element burns out, you lose the ability to sear, crisp, and caramelize your favorite dishes. A faulty element can also lead to uneven cooking and longer preheat times, turning a simple meal into a frustrating experience. Replacing it is a straightforward fix that restores your oven’s performance and saves you from costly repairs or a new appliance purchase.
This guide reviews nine top-rated oven broil elements, covering compatibility, build quality, and installation ease. Whether you own a GE, Whirlpool, Samsung, or Frigidaire range, you’ll find a reliable replacement that fits your needs and budget. Let’s help you get back to perfect broiling.
CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED “AS IS” AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.
PRYSM WB44T10009 Oven Broil Element Compatible with General Electric, Hotpo…
Best forGE and Hotpoint ranges
- Premium material construction
- Strict quality testing
ConsiderLimited brand compatibility
316203200 Broil Element Fit for Ken-more Frig-idaire Oven
Best forKenmore and Frigidaire models
- Even heat distribution
- High-quality materials
ConsiderLimited model compatibility
PRYSM WB44K10002 Oven Broil Element Compatible with General Electric, Hotpo…
Best forGE and Hotpoint models
- Extensive model compatibility
- High-grade construction
ConsiderNo universal fit
WB44X173 Oven Broil Element Compatible with GE JBS07T1JBS07T1JBS07T1 JBS07T…
Best forMulti-brand oven ranges
- Wide model compatibility
- High-temperature resistant
ConsiderSafety precautions needed
W10856603 9757340 Electric Oven Broil Element 240V 3400W
Best forHigh-power Whirlpool ovens
- High wattage for fast heat
- Multiple replacement numbers
ConsiderSpecific model fit
LXun Upgrade WP9760774 Broil Element Compatible with Crosley KitchenAid Whi…
Best forWhirlpool and KitchenAid combos
- Exceptional durability
- Wide brand compatibility
ConsiderNot for all models
UPGRADED DG47-00037A Range Broil Element Compatible with Samsung Electric F…
Best forSamsung freestanding ranges
- High-quality nickel-chrome
- Fixes common heating issues
ConsiderSamsung only
Frigidaire 316430900 Oven Broil Element for Electric Ranges and Stoves, Black
Best forOEM Frigidaire replacement
- Genuine OEM part
- Exact specification fit
ConsiderRequires skilled installation
WB44T10009 Upper Broil Heating Unit Element Replacement for GE Range Oven
Best forGE and Kenmore broad fit
- Wide model compatibility
- Stable heating performance
ConsiderCheck exact model
PRYSM WB44T10009 – Premium GE Broil Element
The PRYSM WB44T10009 is built with premium materials and undergoes strict testing to ensure long-lasting performance. It’s designed to meet the exact specifications of leading range brands, so you can trust it to heat efficiently and evenly. If your GE, Hotpoint, or RCA oven has been slow to broil or heating unevenly, this element is a solid replacement.
Installation is simple, with step-by-step instructions available on the PRYSM website. You can get back to cooking in no time, without needing a professional. The element directly replaces part numbers 770548, AH249284, EA249284, and PS249284, making it a versatile option for many models.
- Premium material construction
- Strict quality testing
- Easy DIY installation
- Limited brand compatibility
- Check model fit first
AMI PARTS 316203200 – Fit for Kenmore and Frigidaire
Brand: AMI PARTS
A dependable broil element for select Kenmore and Frigidaire ovens.
The AMI PARTS 316203200 broil element is designed for Kenmore, Crosley, and Frigidaire ovens, with a precise fit for models like LFEF3017L, LFEF3048Q, and TEF351EWF. Measuring approximately 12.5 by 18.5 inches, it delivers 3000 watts at 240 volts, ensuring consistent heat distribution for even broiling. This element replaces several part numbers, including 316199900, 832973, and CH3200.
Quality assurance is a priority, as this part is made from high-quality materials and passes rigorous testing by the manufacturer. If your oven is heating unevenly or not broiling at all, this replacement can restore performance. It’s a dependable choice for those specific Kenmore and Frigidaire models.
- Even heat distribution
- High-quality materials
- Multiple replacement numbers
- Limited model compatibility
- Requires exact fit check
PRYSM WB44K10002 – Seamless GE and Hotpoint Fit
The PRYSM WB44K10002 offers extensive compatibility with GE, Hotpoint, and RCA oven models, serving as a direct replacement for part numbers WB44K10002 and WB30X46986. Its high-grade materials and rigorous testing ensure long-lasting performance, so you can rely on it for consistent broiling. This element is essential for providing the high heat needed to crisp and brown food effectively.
Installation is straightforward, with detailed instructions available on the PRYSM website, allowing you to complete the job quickly. Whether you’re replacing a worn-out element or upgrading for better performance, this part is designed to integrate seamlessly. It’s a practical choice for anyone with a compatible GE or Hotpoint range.
- Extensive model compatibility
- High-grade construction
- Quick installation
- No universal fit
- Check exact part number
QYMJDGL WB44X173 – Multi-Brand Compatibility
The QYMJDGL WB44X173 broil element is compatible with GE, Kenmore, and Hotpoint ranges, replacing a wide range of part numbers like WB44X0149, WB44X0150, and WB44X0173. It also fits specific models such as JBP80AS2, JBS06GS1, and Kenmore 21332, making it a versatile replacement option. The element is made from high-quality materials that resist high temperatures, providing stable heating and durability.
Installation requires turning off the oven’s circuit breaker before you begin, ensuring safety. Once installed, this element should restore your oven’s broiling capability without issues. If you need a part that covers multiple brands and models, this is a strong candidate.
- Wide model compatibility
- High-temperature resistant
- Stable heating performance
- Safety precautions needed
- Check compatibility list
MTZUL W10856603 – High Power for Whirlpool
The MTZUL W10856603 is a 240V, 3400W broil element designed for Whirlpool ovens, located at the bottom to supply heat for broiling. It replaces multiple part numbers, including 9757340, W10308476, and CH7340, making it a flexible option for various models. With dimensions of 19.625 inches wide and 19.25 inches long, it’s built to fit specific Whirlpool ranges.
The upgraded materials ensure high performance and durability, resisting wear even with frequent use. This element is compatible with models like 4KWFC120MAW0 and 4KWFE, so you can trust it to deliver consistent heat. If your Whirlpool oven isn’t broiling properly, this replacement can solve the problem.
- High wattage for fast heat
- Multiple replacement numbers
- Upgraded durable materials
- Specific model fit
- Requires exact measurement
LXun WP9760774 – Durable for Whirlpool and KitchenAid
Brand: LXun
A durable, easy-to-install broil element for Whirlpool and KitchenAid.
The LXun WP9760774 broil element is crafted from high-quality materials for exceptional durability, fitting Crosley, KitchenAid, and Whirlpool ranges, stoves, ovens, and microwave combos. It serves as a direct replacement for part numbers 9760774, 1201761, and PS11747304, ensuring a proper fit. This element is built to last, providing consistent heat for your broiling needs.
Installation is quick and easy, with no professional help required, so you can replace your faulty element in minutes. The wide compatibility makes it a practical choice for households with different appliance brands. If you need a reliable upgrade, this element delivers on performance and ease.
- Exceptional durability
- Wide brand compatibility
- Tool-free installation
- Not for all models
- Check part number match
S-Union DG47-00037A – Upgraded for Samsung
The S-Union DG47-00037A is an upgraded broil element for Samsung electric freestanding ranges, made from high-quality nickel-chrome material for durability. It fixes common issues like the oven not heating or broiling unevenly, restoring your appliance’s performance. This element replaces part numbers DG47-00037A, 2087536, and AP4342874, ensuring a precise fit.
Installation is straightforward, and the element is designed to address symptoms such as slow preheat or inconsistent cooking. It’s compatible with a range of Samsung models, making it a versatile replacement. If your Samsung oven needs a reliable heating element, this is a strong option.
- High-quality nickel-chrome
- Fixes common heating issues
- Multiple replacement numbers
- Samsung only
- Check model compatibility
Frigidaire 316430900 – OEM Quality for Frigidaire
Brand: Frigidaire
A genuine Frigidaire broil element for exact OEM replacement.
The Frigidaire 316430900 is an OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) broil element, designed and engineered by Frigidaire to exact specifications. Unlike non-genuine parts, this ensures optimal performance and a perfect fit for your Frigidaire electric range. It’s a black element that matches the original, so you can trust its quality.
Installation requires a 1/4-inch nut driver, cross-head screwdriver, gloves, and safety glasses, and it’s recommended for experienced repair persons. This part is ideal for those who want a genuine replacement that guarantees compatibility. If you prefer OEM parts for peace of mind, this is the choice.
- Genuine OEM part
- Exact specification fit
- Trusted brand quality
- Requires skilled installation
- Check manual for fit
Earthtec WB44T10009 – Broad GE and Kenmore Fit
The Earthtec WB44T10009 broil element is designed for GE, Kenmore, and GE Spectra range ovens, replacing part numbers like WB44T10009, CH44T10009, and AP2030995. It fits a wide array of models, including JBP23DIR1BB, JBP23DN1WW, and JBP66CK2CC, making it a versatile option. The element is built to provide stable heating for effective broiling.
Installation is simple, but you must disconnect the power supply and wait for the old element to cool before replacing it. This safety step ensures a smooth process. If you need a reliable replacement for multiple GE or Kenmore models, this element covers many bases.
- Wide model compatibility
- Stable heating performance
- Easy installation with safety
- Check exact model
- Requires power disconnection
Buyer’s Guide: What to Consider
Choosing the right broil element involves more than just picking a part. Consider these key factors to ensure you get a replacement that works efficiently and lasts. This guide will help you make an informed decision.
- Compatibility: Always verify that the broil element matches your oven's brand and model number. Check the user manual or the old part's number to ensure a perfect fit, as using an incompatible element can lead to poor performance or safety issues.
- Wattage and Voltage: The wattage and voltage of the element must match your oven's specifications. Higher wattage provides faster heating, but only if your oven is designed for it. Using the wrong wattage can damage the oven or cause uneven cooking.
- Material Quality: Look for elements made from high-quality materials like nickel-chrome or stainless steel. These resist high temperatures and corrosion, ensuring long-lasting performance. Cheaper materials may degrade quickly, leading to frequent replacements.
- Installation Difficulty: Consider your DIY skill level. Some elements come with detailed instructions and are easy to install, while others may require professional help. Always disconnect power and let the oven cool before starting any repair.
- Brand vs. OEM: OEM parts, like the Frigidaire 316430900, are made by the original manufacturer and guarantee a perfect fit. Aftermarket parts, such as those from PRYSM or AMI PARTS, offer cost savings and often similar quality, but always check reviews and compatibility.
Conclusion
Replacing a faulty broil element is a practical fix that restores your oven’s performance. From the OEM Frigidaire 316430900 to versatile aftermarket options like the PRYSM WB44T10009, there’s a suitable choice for every major brand. Always prioritize compatibility and quality to ensure safe and effective operation.
For most users, the PRYSM WB44T10009 offers a great balance of durability and ease, while the S-Union DG47-00037A is ideal for Samsung owners. If you have a Frigidaire, the OEM part is the safest bet. Whichever you choose, follow the installation instructions carefully to get back to perfect broiling.
Erica Steven is the founder and lead writer of WorstBrands, a site dedicated to providing honest and trustworthy reviews about outdoor gear and fashion products.
With a passion for exploring the great outdoors and staying up to date on the latest fashion trends, Erica uses her expertise to provide valuable insights into the products that matter most to her readers.
Whether you're looking for camping equipment or the latest fashion accessories, Erica's articles are the perfect resource for finding the best products that fit your lifestyle.